Monday, 7 November 2011

Rohit Arya talks on The Sociology of Indian Cinema at ISB, Hyderabad




SB - Leadership Colloqium
Sociology of Indian Cinema
{This talk was given in 2005} 
At the ISB, we always try to innovate on the programme in all its dimensions – the content, delivery, methodology, and bringing in the extras. The Leadership colloqiums are offered as a part of the Leadership Development Programme . The colloquium offers students an opportuntity to interact with leaders in various areas.

Our speaker this week is Rohit Arya who is an exceptional thinker, writer and speaker. He will talk on the "Sociology of Indian Cinema" covering a variety of themes that has come to dominate our collectivity.

The talk discussed Indian cinema, which is uniquely positioned in the new millennium for two reasons. One, it is the only cinema in the world which has not only withstood the juggernaut that is Hollywood but thrived while doing so. Two, it has, by default, become the overarching mode of social discourse in India. No other media or institution has anything remotely close to its influence over the popular imagination - either in terms of defining aspirations or in consensus about what constitutes ‘correct’ social norms, behaviours and mores. The impact of cinema has been so great that it has become the driving engine of mass culture and in many cases threatens to subsume it entirely.

Arya went on to discuss how the cinema in India was never a mirror held up to reality; reality was too grim to be gazed upon. In seeking to escape through entertainment, cinema became a buttress to the collective unconscious, its strivings, desires and aspirations, of the nation. The popular cinema catalogued the unconscious imperatives of a people as well as their responses to the greatest psychological challenge of the 20th century for traditional societies – Modernity.

He said Indian society tends to view complex issues as manifestations of moral choices, hence the endless agonizing over the ‘rightness’ of actions performed. The technologically optimistic goal of a fully industrialized, modernized society was held up as a social panacea for decades. When it came to the crunch, the necessary behavioral and structural changes to make this transition were deemed too disruptive of traditional norms. This push-pull, fascination-repulsion with modernity is fully implicit in our movies. It usually takes on the guise of aggressively condemning the West for being ethically inferior in social and familial terms to India. Meanwhile the Indian problems remain but at least one does not feel as despondent about it. 



Talking about the stereotypes of everyday experience in social reality, Arya said they are never seriously challenged; but are accepted gratefully as raw material and as convenient shorthand to establish context. What the cinema values is not growth and change in people and society but the appearance of it. “What we need are some brand new clichés’, said Sam Goldwyn and the sentiment has never been seriously challenged. Superficial portrayal of The Other - communities, countries and people - creates the facile impression of engagement and strengthens one’s inherent position. The cinema in India fulfills a great need for social reassurance; it validates cultural and social values, especially in comparison with what might be considered more successful or westernized segments of society. To enormous numbers of people Indian cinema provides a readymade structure or prism to view the greater society around them and its influence is truly startling.

In dealing with love for instance, it was not the experience of the emotion and its huge transformative power that was the concern of the cinema. Arya claimed that what concerned filmmakers was the ‘right’ moral solution to what is essentially a transgression of social boundaries. The ‘appropriate’ response to a romantic impulse that leads to honor killings in rural India is difficult to formulate; much easier to lapse into resolutions which take a high ethical tone for the edification and satisfaction of the audience. Love in Indian cinema, as is every other theme, is not as it is but how it ought to be. This cinematic preference for a moral ideal as opposed to complex reality informs most social discourse in India and is responsible for much of the sanctimonious and self-righteousness that characterizes it.

In being informed about the underlying paradigm that drives cinematic representation we recognize many of the deep well springs of social motivations. These are the unconsciously shared belief systems of hundreds of millions of people and perceived immunity to its influence is neither certain nor absolute. The language and grammar of popular cinema has become India’s version of Esperanto, the one universal and instantly understood mode of communication. The impact of cinema has been so great that it has become the driving engine of mass culture and in many cases threatens to subsume it entirely.

In the end analysis, Arya said that an understanding of India was incomplete without an understanding of Indian cinema. 

Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath.

No comments:

Post a Comment